Game Boy vs. Game Boy Color: Which One Should You Buy?

Ever found an old Game Boy tucked away in a drawer or attic and wondered, “Is this the original, or a Game Boy Color?” Well, you’re not alone. 

At first, they seem almost identical; same general shape, same Nintendo logo, but when you look at them closely, the differences are pretty obvious. 

Most people, especially non-gamers, mix them up just because of the names, and the Game Boy Color can still run the original’s games. 

But that’s kind of like saying the NES and SNES are the same thing just because they both have Mario. 

When it comes to Game Boy vs. Game Boy Color, the color isn’t the only difference; there’s a lot more under the hood.

Let’s dig deep! 

The Major Difference: Game Boy vs. Game Boy Color

Put the handhelds side by side, and the first thing you’ll notice is the size. 

The original Game Boy is basically a little brick, chunky, heavy, and built like it could survive a drop off the couch (or maybe even the stairs). 

The Game Boy Color slimmed things down. It’s lighter, fits better in your hands, and is way easier to carry around. Still sturdy, but it doesn’t quite have that “indestructible tank” feel the OG had.

Where things really get interesting is inside:

Processor

The first Game Boy ran at 4.19 MHz, while the Color could kick it up to 8.39 MHz in “double-speed” mode. That bump made games feel smoother and let developers add more complex animations.

RAM

The OG had just 8 KB of work RAM and 8 KB of video RAM. The Color packed in 32 KB of work RAM and 16 KB of video RAM — way more room for bigger worlds and more going on in each game.

Display

The old screen gave you that classic green-and-gray look. The Color blew that wide open, with a 15-bit screen, capable of showing 56 colors at once from a huge 32,000-color palette. Even older games got a splash of color when you played them on it.

Infrared Port

 The GBC even had a little infrared port on top for short-range wireless play. It wasn’t used all that much, but in games like Pokémon Gold and Silver, it powered the Mystery Gift feature and let players swap small items — not full Pokémon trades. A few third-party accessories also made use of it.   

A Tale of Two Batteries

Remember the days when you had to lug around a giant pack of AA batteries just to get through a long car ride? 

The battery situation is one of the most stark differences between the original Game Boy and the Game Boy Color.

• Original Game Boy: This thing ran on four AA batteries and could last for a whopping 30-35 hours. That’s an entire weekend of continuous gaming!
  
  

• Game Boy Color: This was more of a sprinter that used two AA batteries for 10-12 hours of playtime. The color screen was a power hog, but the trade-off was worth it for most people.

The Sound of Silence (and Not-So-Silent Beeps)

Sound is a deeply personal topic for Game Boy fans; it’s just iconic on the original system. 

It produced those crunchy chiptunes that defined an entire era of video game music. 

For many, its raw, unmodified sound is more enjoyable. 

Just listen to the original Tetris theme and you’ll know what we’re talking about.

The Game Boy Color didn’t hit the same notes. 

Programs like LSDj (Little Sound DJ) often perform better on the original Game Boy, as its sound chip produces a cleaner, more authentic chiptune sound.

How to Tell Authentic Cartridges from Clones

This is a hot topic for both collectors and new gamers. 

With so many fakes floating around on the internet, knowing how to spot a real cartridge is essential. 

There are three types of cartridges to look for.

A Collector’s Table Guide to Game Boy Cartridges

This Nintendo handheld comparison guide for GB and GBC cartridges will help make the best choice.

Note: Don’t be fooled by the color of the cartridge! Just because a game has color doesn’t mean it’s a GBC exclusive. The physical cartridge shape is the most reliable way to tell.

Is the Game Boy Color a "Mid-Gen Refresh"?

This is a fun debate that has been going on for years. 

The Game Boy Color was released nine years after the original Game Boy. 

That’s a long time! 

So why do people often call it a “mid-generation refresh” and group its sales together with the original?

The argument for it being a new console is solid: it had:

• New hardware

• New screen

• Games that couldn’t be played on the original

So, GBC was a true successor.

The argument for it being a refresh is also compelling: 

• It was fully backwards compatible, so your old games still worked.
  
  

• It had a short lifespan of about three years before the GBA.
  
  

• Nintendo's strategy focused on iterative upgrades, not new generations.

Regardless of what you call it, the Game Boy Color was a huge step forward for handheld gaming. 

A Quick Comparison Table: Game Boy vs. Game Boy Color

Take a look at this table highlighting the Game Boy comparison with the Game Boy Color.

So, Which One Should You Get? 

This is the real question regarding Game Boy vs. Game Boy Color.

The answer, like with most things in retro gaming, is that it depends.

• If you’re a purist and love that retro feel, the green-tinted screen, the crunchy chiptune sound, and longer battery life, the original Game Boy is hard to beat. It’s the raw, classic handheld experience.
  
  

• If you’re more of an enthusiast who wants a bigger game library, brighter visuals, and better performance, the Game Boy Color makes way more sense. You’ll get access to all the exclusive GBC titles plus colorized versions of the older ones.

In short, both systems are special in their own way and show how handheld gaming went from simple beginnings to something way bigger. 

No matter which one you choose, you’re going to have a good time. Just make sure of making an informed choice.

Get your favorite at RetroFam - expertly restored and backed by a 1-year functional warranty.

Explore The Evolution of the Nintendo Game Boy: From Classic to Color!